Rate Albums
Cover of In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3

In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3

Coheed and Cambria

30 March 2003

Emo, Post-Hardcore, Progressive Rock

Wikipedia

Average
6.6
Ratings
9
Your rating
Log in to rate
Reviews
4
Lists
0
Tracklist 23 tracks, 1:10:48
  1. 1The Ring in Return2:07
  2. 2In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 38:13
  3. 3Cuts Marked in the March of Men5:01
  4. 4Three Evils (Embodied in Love and Shadow)5:09
  5. 5The Crowing6:36
  6. 6Blood Red Summer4:05
  7. 7The Camper Velourium I: Faint of Hearts5:21
  8. 8The Camper Velourium II: Backend of Forever5:23
  9. 9The Camper Velourium III: Al the Killer4:15
  10. 10A Favor House Atlantic3:55
  11. 11The Light & the Glass9:39
  12. 12[silence]0:15
  13. 13[silence]0:06
  14. 14[silence]0:06
  15. 15[silence]0:06
  16. 16[silence]0:06
  17. 17[silence]0:06
  18. 18[silence]0:06
  19. 19[silence]0:06
  20. 20[silence]0:06
  21. 21[silence]0:06
  22. 22[silence]0:09
  23. 2321:139:46

Reviews

5/10

As whiny as it is grandiose, it's music made in a lab to appeal to teenagers. And honestly, good for them. Not as fun as MCR, though.

4/10

Wow, that was awful.

8/10

A Favor House Atlantica is one of those great songs that clearly show off all of the excellent parts of Coheed. Broadly I think this is an album for and a band for huge fans. If you are in it, you are in it for the long haul and are in the deep end. The area for casuals like me is very small. When their songs hit for me, few bands scratch the same spot. But the lore, narrative, and textual density keep me in the small shallows.

6/10

One of those albums I liked when I was 14, but doesn’t really land with me now. But still think we could make room for it on the list.