For this review, I will not factor in the second disc of remixes with the 20th-anniversary edition.
I have heard of The Avalanches before as an electronic group. I remember listening to their third album, We Will Always Love You, and liking that release. However, it was only today that I learned the subgenre they belong to, called "plunderphonics". The compositions are entirely composed of samples merged and twisted together, such that fragments barely resemble the original piece and create a new whole. It's a similar type of song construction that DJ Shadow implemented for Entroducing, which was my second album on this journey. In that sense, I enjoyed The Avalanches' debut album, Since I Love You, as much as I did Endtroducing.
Drawing back to that subgenre definition, I enjoyed how the samples were used to create these new danceable sounds and atmospheres, and how the tracks interweave from one into the next. Some personal highlights include the string samples and youthful vocal snippets on the opening title track, the swaying beats, wind instruments, and electronic loops that move to a 3/4 time signature in "Two Hearts in 3/4 Time", the drums from Vaughan Mason and Crew's "Bounce, Rock, Skate, Roll" paired with the filtered female soprano vocals and synthesizers on "Electricity", and the horns and driving percussion paired with the twisted sample of a comedy sketch on "Frontier Psychiatrist".
However, as much as I enjoyed the creativity on display and the interconnected nature of the songs, the album does drag in places, particularly between "Flight Tonight" and "Electricity," where the disco styling can feel one-note in its direction. The songs in this lull may not be bad, but they are not as ambitious as those I previously highlighted.
Still, I recognize why Since I Left You is a pioneering album in its niche. In that regard, it comes with a solid recommendation.
Update 5/13/2025: I decided to revisit Since I Left You upon nearing 300 albums into my journey, and I realized what didn't work for me with this record. It's the overall length of the album that I feel is a problem, running at a little over an hour. Contrary to the perceived lull in my initial review, there isn't a bad track on this album per se, and I do appreciate how each track in its intriguing sample manipulation neatly flows into one another. But after a while, it does start to drag a bit from my perspective.
Again, I still enjoyed this album despite the length. It is a pioneering album for plunderphonics, one that certainly demands attention from the listener but is rewarding for all the little details and nuances that can be picked up in the construction.