For a debut from such a young artist, this is such a mature effort. She made this when she was 18! Even the vocals are so mature and feel imbued with lived experience. She has that kind of drawling, husky energy that hits.
The production is super cool, with great use of instrumentation to create layered soundscapes. It's a real mood piece throughout. I genuinely thought Jon Brion produced this album as it has many of his hallmarks, but apparently not - but actually looking now I see he did actually play a bunch of instruments across it, which makes sense. I love that vibraphone sound in particular, and the use of violins and bells.
I don't know why I seem to gravitate towards 'sad female singer' artists, but I really do. Who knows what that says about me! Anyway, there's plenty of sadness in here. Never is a Promise is heart-breaking, but really effective. There's a real vulnerability, but also quiet resolve. Criminal is the most talked about track, and it really is a standout. There's a danger and sexiness to it.
I've listened to this album a bunch over the years, but I'm actually appreciating some of my lesser-listened tracks this time around. Particularly 'The First Taste' which has a real depth to the production.
This is a superb debut, bravo!
4.5 rounded up.