20 in 2024: Love is Hell
Ryan Adams, singer and songwriter who had a super prolific run of records spanning the late 90's up to today, over 20 albums in his name makes for one busy guy. He earned his reputation being one of the most popular musicians in his lane, with lots of classics under his belt. Though during the 2010's he has been outed as being a serial harasser and general sex pest to many women in the industry, therefore tarnishing his overall reputation and rightfully so. This dude is a scumbag.
With that to consider, this album is kind of painted in a new light 20 years later. At the time of it's release, this record was actually two EP's released separately at the behest of the record label. Being labeled as "too alternative" for a full official release. Though because the EP's were so popular, it got an official pressing in 2004 as a full LP. The record itself is pretty much a concept record of how shitty at relationships our protagonist(s) are in these songs, and not to mention the opening track which alludes to Jack and Meg White's divorce. So yeah, this album is kind of messy topic-wise, but that's also sort of reflected in the music too.
This record is a hodgepodge of different rock styles ranging from Coldplay-esque alt rock, to heartland rock a la Springsteen, to blues-oriented country-tinged balladeering. Stylistically incoherent, it leaves a rather strange taste in my mouth for that reason, though due to this it does have many layers and different dimensions to explore the material in the music as well. It's rather interesting honestly.
The opening track "Political Scientists" is a pretty stark opening that contrasts really stripped down verses with explosive choruses. Adams sounds like a mix of Thom Yorke and Kurt Cobain, going from his whispery quiet singing to loud and emotional yelping. This is none more felt than on a song like the title track, which is a more upbeat jangle-pop song sort of similar to something you would hear from The Stone Roses.
The first leg of this album is by far the strongest. "Afraid Not Scared" is another pretty sullen track that continues the slow burn set by the opener, while "This House is Not For Sale" reels in the Heartland rock quite suddenly but welcomingly as the pace picks up for some of the album's most upbeat tracks. "Anybody Wanna Take Me Home" is a desperate plea of someone who's drank too much and needs people to help him, despite no apparent help coming. The title track is probably one of the best songs here as the cries of "love is hell!!!!" can be felt in your soul.
The biggest surprise this album had in store for me was the cover of Oasis's defining single "Wonderwall". Which was once a wistful and lovestruck ballad, has now turned into a desperate and disturbing wail of love unrequited. It's haunting, and the change in key from the original just sends shivers down my spine. This song transitions wonderfully into "The Shadowlands" which is another haunting ballad about a drug abusive husband who's torn his family apart due to his destructive habits. By far the darkest song in the record. The first half of the song being a sullen piano ballad, and then the song turns into two minute rock jam as the emotion ramps up. The first half of this record ends with "Avalanche", a gut wrenching rock ballad that describes the distance felt after a breakup. Pretty effective in how it ties up the first side of this double LP.
So yeah so far I really really enjoy the first half here. The second half though is a bit more underwhelming to me honestly. The songs are still decent to pretty good. The ballads are a bit more understated here though and feel a bit more lifeless compared to the high points of the former half of the record. "My Blue Manhattan" feels like a Chet Baker song if it were rendered in 2005, which makes for a concept that is more interesting as an idea than a song for me. "City Rain" is a welcome change in pace though, it picks the pace up a bit but hits us with an intense bout of self pity and self deprecation, as Adams admits to ruining someone's life to the point of announcing them as "having died". The peppy instrumental offsets this shocking string of lyrics. "I See Monsters" is a bit of a creepy song about the protagonist being awake while his partner is sleeping. Admiring her beauty and gentleness while "all he can see is monsters". Whether this reflects the paranoid ownership of the protagonist, or a self reflection on his own capability to be a monster (I think maybe a mix of both), this song still manages to make me want to take a shower.
"Hotel Chelsea Nights" ends things off on a rather epic note. The song plays like a rock jam, with some bluesy organs and a raspy sung and loose vocal delivery. Lyrically talking about how much Adams desires to no longer live in the Chelsea Hotel in NYC. Which is famous for housing many famous writers and songwriters over the years. More than just a desire to leave NYC though, Adams explores the idea of maybe getting lost in the fog, disappearing entirely, and just going away. A pretty apt way to close the record off I would say.
Yeah all in all I do really like this record. It has a pretty consistent mood despite the constant stylistic shifts, and the lyricism is really good and Adams is by all means a fantastic songwriting, and vocalist. Sometimes the influences can be felt a little hard, and the album's length can definitely be felt on the second half of the record BUT considering all that this album is a satisfying listen when you're in the mood for some depressing ass music.
When considering the kind of asshole that Ryan Adams is, and the lyrical content of this record, it's kind of no wonder that he turned out to be the kind of guy he is. The person being portrayed in the lyrics here is not a good guy, and all these failed relationships and traumas all stem from POV of the person singing the song. If there was an album to be a red flag album in someone's list of favorite records it would be this one to be quite honest. It's interesting to see how self aware Adams was when making this, which is probably why when all of the allegations started coming out he pretty much almost instantly owned up to all of it and accepted the consequences. It doesn't redeem the guy at all mind you, it just feels apt. That's really all I can say.
Anyway, good album, glad I heard it, and happy twentieth birthday I guess!
"I feel like getting rid of all my things
Maybe just disappear into the fog"