As soon as I saw that this album was on the list, I prepared for it. Ghosteen has been framed as the final part of a trilogy of albums spanning Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds' output through the 2010s, following Push the Sky Away and Skeleton Tree. I gave both of those albums a listen to better understand how they would be followed up on. I'm also aware that Nick Cave's son Arthur passed away back in 2015, after much of Skeleton Tree was written. There was a certain expectation festering in my mind of Nick leaning into more grief amidst the electronic and ambient textures that have colored the then-most-recent works. So let me state this for the record - while I admit that this album may be viewed as the "weakest" of the aforementioned trilogy, that is not to excuse how damn potent it is.
I might as well get my nitpicks out of the way, as the idea of Ghosteen being the "weakest" will loom longer if I don't address it. Mainly, my concerns lie with the structuring of this record. It is a double album that does admittedly run long, and requires thoughtful listening as the mixes are so spare and restrained, and the beats are so minimal that attention has to be paid to any tunefulness and poetic frailty that cuts to the front. There aren't any musical climaxes like on Push the Sky Away or any melodic choices that hit as hard as on Skeleton Tree, as the music is largely ambient to allow the listener to sink into the textures. But then there's also a matter of how the two halves of this record are divided - the first disc being eight songs described as "from the children", while the second disc is two long songs split by a spoken word interlude referred to as "from the parents". On a pure musical level, there's a certain awkwardness with the sequencing in terms of building towards those emotional climaxes. The first disc ending on "Leviathan" may make sense lyrically, but sonically it does feel a tad incomplete, where the end of disc two on "Hollywood" is more jarring with the minor key brittleness that comes off as a rather bleak way to end an otherwise ethereal experience.
Yet, there is something truly mesmerizing in this album's minimalist compositions. Take for example the fuzzed-out, clanking introduction to "Waiting for You" that lasts a few seconds before the song shifts to an outright piano ballad, or the faint, muffled stutter of the ascending guitar against the gentle warmth of the strings on "Sun Forest", or the vocal pickups that build such a striking foundation on "Galleon Ship", or the little synth flourishes on "Ghosteen Speaks", or even the hand percussion touches around a mix of faint electronic layers and melodic swell off the piano chords on "Leviathan". Even if there isn't a defined groove, the rich cushion of atmosphere and effective use of negative space made up for the lack of any explicit hook.
Of course, when the musical landscape is largely atmospheric, the logical centerpiece in this mix is Nick Cave himself, with a painfully aching vocal delivery that can still command gravitas. He assumes the focal point as the storyteller for the abstract stories that need to be told. There are some genuinely striking moments coming from his voice, such as the full-throated singing on "Waiting for You", the accompanying backing chorus on "Sun Forest" and "Spinning Song", and the female vocals sliding behind him on "Night Raid".
As for the content with which Nick uses that voice, there is a continuation of certain metaphors and points of reference from the previously mentioned works. The burning trees and creatures rising from the ocean that were on Push the Sky Away are used in such apocalyptic scenery, as the children ascend towards the sun in a similar iconography to the passing through worlds witnessed on Skeleton Tree. This leads into the larger text of Ghosteen as rooted in the healing of grief and heartbreak that came from Nick Cave losing his son, now left to reconcile with the son's passage into another plane of existence that he can't contextualize. Alongside that, there had been a long-running subtext through these albums about the music itself - the questions of advancing artistry into untold depths on Push the Sky Away, the whole concept of narratives severed on Skeleton Tree, and here with bookending statements about the inevitability of death, yet through art's transmission beyond that life there can be an emotional clarity found between the artist and their audience.
Even still, there's another side to the narrative that has to be mentioned, and that is what Nick himself is left to do back on earth. In the text, Nick is still patching up the lingering pain that he and his wife had endured, while in the subtext, the art has to mend that gap to his audience, to rebuild the faith in his stories and that emotive connection. It's why "Night Raid" retells his son's conception with swirling images of birth and death, the gravitas of the moment symbolized by the returning horses to the street. It's why the fairy tale of Goldilocks and the three bears is recontextualized on the title track to highlight the sense of falling into routine to maintain a lingering connection. Probably most potently on the record, it's why on the interlude "Fireflies", the impossibility of holding on to that cosmic connection is compared to the photons of a dying star, as they inch across space to land their energy. By the time they achieve this feat, they're left as memories. That leads us into "Hollywood" at the end, where life seems cheapened amid a dark, apocalyptic world, as Nick waits to cross that distance himself to reunite with his son. That is, until he recalls the Buddhist tale of Kisa, a woman whose son dies and she searches for answers from the Buddha, only to be told instead to collect a mustard seed from each house whose owner has never lost someone; she could not collect a single one. At this point, the text and subtext are joined: until that great barrier is passed, what we have on earth is all that we got, whether it's the flawed community we find or the audience who will take that conveyance of energy and momentum in art and reflect it on the artist.
If it wasn't apparent, I was moved by this record. Admittedly, I nearly broke down in tears while listening in the office. Ghosteen may not possess the compositional bombast of its preceding records, but that doesn't stop it from being a sonically gorgeous, nuanced, and striking effort. There is a command of atmosphere and intricacy that I can't help but be moved by. While complete peace may be further on down the road, there's enough found here that was made beautiful.