For this review, I am looking at the original release of this album. I will not include the four-song EP "A Something's Extra" that gets tacked on to the end of the CD and streaming releases.
That still leaves us with a double album that runs for about an hour and a half, and that runtime seems to be the elephant in the room here. As experimental as Stevie gets here, I don't think there's a bad or filler track per se, even though the baby recordings on the album cut of "Isn't She Lovely" are jarring, and some tracks like "Another Star" and "Black Man" go on for longer than they need to.
That said, I do not recommend marathoning this album in one session, because there is such a case for "too much of a good thing." Take a break between discs/records for this one. It belongs on this list, but only when approached with the right mindset.
Update 3/12/2026: Against the advice of my past self, I re-listened to this album in one session. Amazingly, I was not fatigued and thoroughly enjoyed it all the way through.
I will freely admit that I felt intimidated when I got this record so early on in my album journey. I was only a little over two weeks in when this behemoth dropped on me, so I caved in a bit. But, with time, I was able to warm up to longer releases, and that gave me the courage to consider revisiting Songs in the Key of Life, and I was not disappointed.
Credit to Stevie himself for being a masterful lyricist, songwriter, and multi-instrumentalist on this record, as he knew how to make a song engaging and thought-provoking in sonic and poetic detail. Songs like "Another Star" and "Black Man", upon re-listening, were some of the most fun extended funk jams I heard in some time with such aspirational messaging. Even the baby recordings on "Isn't She Lovely" now sound right at home as Stevie sang a heartfelt tribute to his daughter. Not to mention other highlights like the ominous synth-funk of "Have a Talk with God", the baroque arrangement of "Village Ghetto Land", the boppin' expression of music appreciation on "Sir Duke", the super eclectic horn and bass combo of "I Wish", the Latin beat influence on cuts like "Pastime Paradise" and "Ngiculela - Es Una Historia - I Am Singing", I could keep going on...
I do think it is worth giving Songs in the Key of Life the time of day, and I am glad to have come back to it after so long.