Rated 8/10
I was wondering when I was gonna get a Madonna record on my album journey. It's admittedly hard to ignore the so-called "Queen of Pop". However, the record I'm starting with her here is quite the curveball.
Continuing in the techno-pop direction of Ray of Light, with both returning producer William Orbit and newcomer French DJ and producer Mirwais, Madonna sought to change up her sound again in the turn-of-the-millennium mainstream dominated by the likes of Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera. The fruit of their combined labor would result in the album Music. Sure, the title is unimaginative, but this record actually set a precedent for the next two decades of Madonna's work, as she kept one foot on the pop music zeitgeist while continuing to experiment. In the case of Music, the album is very much the year 2000, for better or worse.
This album is filled to the brim with stuttering electronic beats, squelching basslines, and the adoption of a cowboy kitsch. It very much evokes the time in which it was released. Obviously, it's going to sound dated 25 years after its release because the musical landscape has changed since then, and I don't expect everyone to be as into its blend of techno, electro-house, pop, and country. But as someone who was four years old at the time of this album's release, I cannot deny how much Madonna and this production sell the vibe for the most part. The propulsive, snappy beats and electronic embellishments behind the anthemic title track, that gurgling synth and pulsing bass that are prominent in the space-age club boom of "Impressive Instant", the fast-paced techno flourishes buoying Madonna's rebuke against an unfaithful man on "Runaway Lover", that stuttering acoustic guitar loop that gets built upon for "Don't Tell Me" as she pleaded for her partner to not control her; there are some genuinely intriguing twists and turns with the electronic and techno elements. Though there are a few moments where the energy is dialed back for more acoustic-driven tunes, including the folk ballad "I Deserve It" in dedication to her then-partner Guy Ritchie, followed by the 1960s-inspired pop rock of "Amazing", and the melancholic closer "Gone" as Madonna strummed away on her guitar while reminiscing on this relationship as it comes to a close. Probably the best track on the album for me was "What It Feels Like for a Girl", starting with quoting a Serge Gainsbourg monologue before giving way to a subtle, bouncy beat and supple bass as Madonna addresses the double standards placed onto women by society. It's a surprisingly poignant song coming out of her, combined with such a vibrant ambient production.
Really, the only tracks that didn't work for me were the ones that involved heavy manipulation of Madonna's voice where it wasn't needed. "Nobody's Perfect" saw her voice put through a vocoder, while "Paradise (Not Gone)" made prominent use of the Antares Auto-Tune plug-in set for the non-spoken word portions of the track. For as much as this album is already viewed as a year 2000 record, these two tracks in particular felt indicative of the music industry's response to the use of Auto-Tune in Cher's hit "Believe", and not necessarily for the better. Apparently, from what I read on this album, Madonna actually wanted her voice treated differently in this manner, which Mirwais initially objected to but then ended up using said Auto-Tune for a few of the tracks at her request. Thankfully, it's not on every song on the record, but these two tracks alone feature heavily manipulated vocals where you didn't need them for Madonna of all people, and that's what rubbed me the wrong way.
Still, I overall had a good time with Music, the album. Madonna and her accompanying producers made the most out of what the year 2000 had to offer.