After leaving VU and trying his hand at solo success, then fucking around with ambient soundscapes and classical arrangments, Johnny boy drops an album that is now considered the high point in his discography, and honestly, I can see why musical connoisseurs and ADHD patients on this site would flock around this album.
Cale was at a tough part of his career. After leaving VU he struggled to find his footing and release something that would wow the audience. Sure, Vintage Violence had somewhat given him attention around mainstream circles, but his next two albums really pushed him back, so he needed somewhat of a prized dog in the competition, especially since some other guy from some other band Cale noodles with in the 60s had released a seminal album a year prior.
Enter Paris 1919 (don't enter Paris in 1919, but enter the album), an ambitional endeavor only a few musicians could pull off successfully. Cale mixed bright and luscious orchestral instrumentation with his seasoned songwriting chops and gave it everything he had.
A3 and A4 are really enjoyable pieces. I liked "Half Past France" with its slow descent into orchestral playing and "Macbeth" is the only song on here that has that teeth-grinding edge, while "Antarctica Starts Here" with its subdued nature caps off the album beautifully. A1 and 2 are a slow start to the album, but have some interesting tidbits, mainly the instrumental arrangments. Only "Graham Greene" is a song I would routinely skip.
And after all of that, the album didn't invoke any emotion in me. Sad, I know. It has everything that a good album should have. Good instrumentation, competent songwriting, and the vocals are nice, but it just misses that ingredient that grabs you by the shoulders and yeets you across the room. This album gently sways you from side to side instead.
All in all, a pretty happy album with exquisite instrumentation. For me though, it feels kinda like day-old bread. Can I eat it? Sure. But will I be satisfied with it? Maybe, but fresh bread is fresh bread. Day-old bread is not something I would be proud of. Not much more to say other than that really. Cale rides the wave of success of Paris 1919 through 1973. I hope nothing bad happens on a particular night in May 1974 just before a particular show that was documented on a particular album.