I dunno, should I give a bonafide classic 5 stars just because it's a bonafide classic?
Should I weigh the pros and cons of each track though a modern prism and say things like "Fire" is some basic ass lyrics; it's just "let me stand next to your fire" over and over...
Should I say something inflammatory like, while Hendrix's guitar playing was revolutionary at the time, he's really just a cut rate Jack White and can't hold a candle to The Edge.
No, that would be foolish, because this is a bonafide classic and it deserves its 5 stars, deserves and earns.