I started a review, scrapped it and started over. I grew up in this era I didn't listen to this album. This album was out at the heigh of the 2000's/90's girl vs girl drama the media pushed (Christina vs. Brittney, Monica vs. Brandy, Mariah vs. JLo). This specific rivalry Christina was the 'dirty' one pushing the envelope on the idea of female sexuality, fighting the double standard and embracing a more free lifestyle. I love that idea and applaud the ladies that pushed that envelope and dealt with the pushback.
But this album focuses too much on pushing the boundaries, buying into the person the media made her and not focusing on what she was really good at, singing (and not always crazy vibrato way). There are a few highlights that show her talent, The Voice Within, Keep on Singin, even Dirrty. But then there was Walk Away, Make Over, Loving me 4 me, they are trying so hard to play into the sexual side that they become cheesy and way over the top. It was like she was trying to hide her voice, and use all these other tricks to get people to like the songs, when she didn't need to! I know it says she was heavily involved in the writing and this was her premiere album, but it doesn't hold up (I have no loyalty to her or Ms. Spears). This album is too much, too over the top, making it overall of a bad example of early 2000's pop music. I will still dance and sing along at the top of my longs to Dirrty and Fighter, but overall this album does Ms. Aguilera Dirrty and doesn't spend enough time letting her show off her strongest asset, her voice.