This was a very formative album for me when I was a young hip-hop fan. But it was also very formative for hip-hop in general, at a time when the genre was transitioning into its very glossy, blingy, 2000's form. I'm talking the high-pitched soul samples, a weird obsession with eastern samples, RnB-etched choruses, and, um Eminem...it's all here. The opening 'The Ruler's Back' feels almost like a starter's pistol for this new era of, not only hip-hop but popular culture in general. It's such a grand-sounding opener with this cinematic horn-backed instrumental. It's also, at its core, a Jay-Z comeback song after a very dry run in the '90s following his impeccable debut 'Reasonable Doubt'. I always preferred 'Ether' to 'Takeover' in the Nas/Jay-Z beef, but the 'The Doors' sample here, courtesy of Kanye, makes me prefer the production here generally. 'Girls Girls Girls' seems to get off on just how offensive it can be, but it admittedly gets at least a small chuckle out of me. It also has some of the best sample chopping here, and its sister Pt2 track is just as lush-sounding. Also, there's a dizzying amount of features on this song, like Q-tip and MJ are on here. It's "All of the Lights" before the fact. Other great production moments come in the form of the title track with those sweet organs, 'Heart Of The City' with its almost west-coast sounding flute and guitar-driven beat (and a very catchy chorus). And while 'Izzo (H.O.V.A.)' uses a very obvious 'Jackson 5' sample, it's still always been one of my favorite beats here...it speaks to Kanye's talents as a young producer at the time. Plus, Jay-Z was never one to avoid obvious samples.
And yeah Jay-Z is a great rapper. He's sort of like Tupac in many ways - he's an MC who values his choppy flow, cadence, and timing over pummeling the listener with back-to-back punchlines and wordplay. And he's in prime form here, even if he does get out-rapped by Eminem on 'Renegade' - which, unironically has my favorite Eminem performance ever, his own music included. The standout is obviously 'Song Cry' on the lyrical front. It's a precursor to "4:44" in many ways with Jay-Z tearing his ego to shreds. But he does it very subtly which is what makes this song so powerful to me. Because it's really not until the last line "I got to live with the fact I did you wrong forever" that Jay-Z takes this tough-boy mask off and admits his wrongdoing within the relationship. It's only one line but it says more than the rest of this very blame-evasive track does. I always thought this was a really important song for hip-hop.
This album feels like staring up at the Empire State Building. It's like '2000s hip-hop in its purest form. No gimmicks here (and surprisingly, for the time, no skits!!), just an enjoyable rap album. I remember loving this thing when I first heard it years ago, it opened my eyes to rap in a way I was previously oblivious to. Listening back to it now, it still sounds as great as ever.