I love this album so much!! It's one long daydream with a uniquely strange atmosphere. I've always found it sort of cold and uncanny in a way - maybe because it's fully composed from hundreds (thousands?) of tiny, disjointed and unrelated snippets mashed together. Its weirdness is its charm! You could draw comparisons to other sample-heavy artists like DJ Shadow and the like - there's even a moment here that reminds me a lot of The Caretaker's work (track 11) - but few defy genre definition quite like The Avalanches.
What's crazy is that it would've been easy for them to go overboard with all the different samples, but they actually show a lot of restraint all while still crafting some wonderfully lush, textured instrumentals. When they *really* let loose, it's on Frontier Psychiatrist, the climax of the album... and GOD it's so perfectly insane! I adore it!! Then on eventual re-listens you even start to spot recurring sounds throughout the project that really give it an extra sense of continuity, so it only gets better over time.
One last note! Remember how I described this album as being a strange, cold and uncanny daydream? I just can't help but bring up by contrast their sophomore album Wildflower, released 16 years later. They lay off the plunderphonics a bit and give way to something delightfully warm, full of life, and still somehow just as daydreamy. I can't recommend the experience enough to those who enjoyed what The Avalanches did on SILY.
Standouts: Since I Left You • Two Hearts In 3/4 Time • Electricity • Tonight May Have To Last Me All My Life • Frontier Psychiatrist • ETOH • Summer Crane • Little Journey • Extra Kings