A love letter to teenage innocence. Through all the darkness that followed The Beach Boys, from Brian Wilson's sustained abuse from his therapist, Dennis Wilson's untimely death, Mike Love's brief stint as the worst frontman of all time, and Brian Wilson's much more timely, but quite sad, death much more recently, this album still stands as one of the most beautiful and wholesome albums ever created. Sweet, but not saccharine, vaguely old-fashioned but not mean or indignant in any way, lush and beautiful, trusting, starry-eyed, magical. I mean, just look at the cover. The band in a candid photo feeding various animals, their offer gazes and plain clothes, the photo not edited that much seemingly, with a bright, lush green title strip plastered above them. Some people disparage this cover, but I love it. It's exactly what a sweet album like this deserves.
The songs back this up too: obviously there's a semblance of "old-timeyness," as seen in songs like "I'm Waiting For The Day," or "Caroline, No," but both of those songs work because, in one case it's a pretty respectful statement of waiting until someone is ready to be in a relationship again, and in the other it's in fact a pretty heartbreaking and beautiful example of what could be a misunderstanding, could be symbolism, but either way shows some sort of deep sadness for the death of innocence, one of the reasons I love this song's placement at the end of the album. Wilson's vocals aren't disgusted, but rather confused and sorrowful at what he seems to barely understand: "you said you'd never change, but that's not true!" it's a feeling of betrayal that the other person perhaps didn't even recognize as betrayal; by changing as a person, Caroline has upended the speaker's understanding of the world merely by doing what every person is bound to do. It's no one's fault, but an innocence has died.
Other songs better portray that innocence, such as the adorable, catchy, lush, heartwarming "Wouldn't It Be Nice," in all of its perfection and childish wonder (fun fact, my dad gave my mom a CD mix starting with that song back in high school!), or "Don't Talk (Put Your Head On My Shoulder)," which instills this beautiful and placid sense of love, and safety: when Wilson sings "We'll live forever tonight..." you believe it, or at least believe that he does. It's just such a simply wonderful song. "Sloop John B," no matter how silly, is not only super musically impressive, but also so fun! It's a fun, innocent tale, which is exactly what this album deserves. I also really enjoy "Here Today," which is both one of the catchiest and one of the wisest songs on the whole album: it does not badmouth the speaker's ex-girlfriend, but simply gives a warning, and one of the truest statements of all: "Love is here today, then it's gone." One of the album's catchiest choruses, a mature sentiment, and an oddly beautiful maxim. The two instrumental songs also add a nice atmosphere to the album, with the placid nature of "Let's Go Away For Awhile," and the lush and beautiful musical passages on title track "Pet Sounds." And then we have perhaps the greatest song on this album, "G-d Only Knows." Oh, the times I've sung this song, in the shower, with my dad, on guitar, on piano. A simple idea expanded into one of the sweetest, most genuine love songs ever written, with some of the best harmonies ever put to tape, one of the greatest song progressions ever conceived, and one of the most emotional climaxes of any song ever. It is truly a wonder of a song, and I can't say I trust the taste of anyone who doesn't at least respect it for that.
There's also a separate underlying theme on the album, however: a sense of self-improvement. Songs like "That's Not Me," one of my personal favorites, or "You Still Believe In Me," point to a sadness brought on by one's own inability to live up to others' and also one's own expectations. In "That's Not Me," Wilson sings "I once had a dream, so I packed up and moved to the city / I soon found out that my lonely life wasn't so pretty." It's a song of hope for a greater good winning out inside one's own heart and practices, seen similarly in "You Still Believe In Me," which exclaims a passionate appreciation for the speaker's lover, who, even after all the speaker has done wrong, still believes in the good in him, and by extension, him. Later in the album, these themes are returned to: in "I Know There's An Answer," the speaker laments at the unfulfilling way people live their lives, claiming that he "[could not] tell them their lives could be better," and that the answer has to be found out by oneself. Similarly, the problems that are talked about in that song can be seen in "I Just Wasn't Made For These Times," where the chorus is the simple, but circumstantially heartbreaking line "Sometimes, I feel very sad," a feeling of detachment and depression. It's simultaneously the moment that betrays the album's maturity and its innocence plainly: though it sings plainly about the problems in one's life it does so just like that: plainly. It doesn't have mature words for the deep feelings that might be being felt, but it must voice its opinion anyway, in the same way that a child might do. The album as a whole reflects this, childlike and simple in nature, but sensitive, wise, and mature in thought.
The production is also incredible. Impossibly lush, mixed to perfection, the music surrounds you but never quite overwhelms you. The Boys' choral performances are incredible, and the arrangements are spectacular. Each backing track reflects exactly what should be reflected: the beauty and innocence that populates this album. It is truly perfect in every way. This album, though to many quickly dethroned by The Beatles' Revolver, will never lose the place it holds in my heart as one of the best albums ever recorded, with some of the best songs ever written on it. I don't think I could love this album more if I tried harder than I already have.
10/10
DOES IT BELONG ON THE LIST: ABSOLUTELY
REASON: Seminal, beautiful, perfect.