Rated 8/10
Two months ago, I listened to Heartattack and Vine and enjoyed it, acknowledging that it was a transitional record in Tom Waits's catalog and that I was looking forward to what happened next. Well, here's what happened next...
After completing a soundtrack album for the film One from the Heart, Tom parted ways with his long-time producer, Bones Howe, and manager Herb Cohen. He was determined to break away from the sound of his earlier records, especially after his wife, Kathleen Brennan, introduced him to more avant-garde music. As a result, Swordfishtrombones saw Tom split the difference between vaudeville-esque orchestration, influences from the likes of Delta blues and Captain Beefheart, and his own unique songwriting style and production.
This album is unorthodox, simply put. The metallic clangs that illicit a chain gang vibe for the bluesy "16 Shells from a Thirty-Ought Six", the blaring bagpipes that give way to the lowly organ dirge of "Town with No Cheer", the accordion-led slow-burn showtune interlude of "Just Another Sucker on the Vine", the invocation of New Orleans swamp music ala Dr. John with the prominent marimba on cuts like "Shore Leave" and the title track, there's variety in the instrumentation and arrangement for these songs. All the while, Tom imbues his stories with extended metaphors and deliberate obfuscation, as the world-weary narrator gazes upon the seeded underbelly of this setting. Even the ballads aren't safe from his twisted humor, such as tattooing his wife's name on his arm in "Johnsburg, Illinois", or the grumpy old man observations of his surroundings on "In the Neighborhood". It's demented showmanship delivered through Tom's gravelly delivery and his equally off-putting instrumental accompaniment, and I enjoyed it to an extent.
My hangup with this unique songwriting and album-construction approach is that there's little in the way of forming a cohesive narrative from one track to the next. Also not helping matters is how a lot of these tracks are short, half the album clocking in at two minutes or less, leaving me with the feeling that some of these tracks could have been fleshed out more.
I do feel like Tom Waits made significant progress in developing his own sound on Swordfishtrombones, and I commend his wife for encouraging him to further push the envelope. I'm certain the best is yet to come.