I will not include the appended CD bonus tracks or 2002 re-release bonus tracks for this review.
Ahh, yes, one of the "worst albums" according to the global stats for this generator, and had me genuinely curious. For those who are unfamiliar, Einstürzende Neubauten is a German experimental music group led by Blixa Bargeld, who would later become a founding member of Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds. One of the trademarks of the group is that they utilize self-made or found objects as instrumentation, such as metal plates. While they will use these unorthodox instruments for more conventional sounds in later recordings, their early work is notably harsh as Bargeld would scream and shout over banging and scraping metal percussion. Case in point, their debut album, Kollaps, is defined by that style.
This album can make or break people without more formal introductions to elements of industrial, experimental, and German music. Thankfully, I've taken multiple courses in music analysis back in college, and I got this record after over 300 albums into my journey, including records that would fit into the above categories. I can't imagine the poor soul who got this as their first album without any prior understanding or context of what the group is trying to accomplish here.
With that in mind, I do enjoy this record to an extent. There's an almost primal feel in the abrasive nature of Blixa's harsh vocals over the obtuse percussive elements that weirdly maintain a good sense of rhythm. It must be cathartic for a German music group coming out of post-World War II Berlin, trying to make a living, and experiencing both the frustration and vulnerability of what it must have taken to reconstruct, represented by the use of noises that would be associated with construction equipment. It certainly made for a unique experience that doesn't immediately deter me away, especially with how creative they get, such as the pitter patter of water before the visceral screaming on "Negative Nein" or the literal drill beat that opens "Steh auf Berlin", and the twisted instrumental rendition of Serge Gainsbourg's "Je t'aime... moi non plus" that adds a bit of black humor.
Yet, for as much as this album clicked for me, there are still issues I have with it. Besides the obvious lack of cohesion, which may be the point, some songs tend to make a more lasting impression than others. Given the multitude of short tracks that run under two minutes, there isn't as much room to allow the compositional identity to sink in before being launched into the next. This sentiment also extends to the closer "Helga", which felt abrupt as an ending with the ten seconds of radio transmission before cutting to silence.
Still, I was intrigued by Kollaps in all its outlandish execution. It's not an album that would easily get made in today's world, with the way the music marketing landscape has shifted, which makes this record feel special.