Staggering riffs, soaring vocals, gigantic drum hits- this is a stone-cold classic metal release. To imbue metal music with this much of a pop sound without losing what makes this band special, with this much care given to a diverse sound (from balladry, to chorus-driven bangers, to slow chuggers, to fast thrash tracks)- there is no denying the power of the Black Album. I love each and every song, and to show that, I'm going to "rank 'em all" here and give a little blurb about why each one works:
12. "The Struggle Within"- military drums at beginning firmly anchor this in the Persian Gulf-era
11. "Don't Tread On Me"- an infectious chorus
10. "Through the Never"- that riff at the end is an all-timer
9. "Enter Sandman"- a classic? yes. but there are even better tracks
8. "The God That Failed"- great bass work and lyrical content
7. "Wherever I May Roam"- sitar intro???? YES
6. "Holier Than Thou"- the pissed-off feeling/attitude permeating from this one has always stuck with me
5. "The Unforgiven"- have always been drawn to the excellent vocal perf on this and 1997's part II in the same series
4. "Sad But True"- it's just so badass- so deliberately dramatic with those drum entrances and insanely well-produced guitar solo work
3. "Of Wolf and Man"- Catchy but still heavy- this one has aged really well production-wise and essentially launched Avenged Sevenfold's entire sound
2. "My Friend of Misery"- that atmospheric section in the middle with the reverb-y guitar laid over the orchestra is just orgasmic
1. "Nothing Else Matters"- a haunting piece of legitimately epic songwriting like no other in the power ballad oeuvre