Layla and Other Assorted Love Songs
I don’t think I’ve listened to this in full before. Layla is rightly part of the rock canon, a brilliantly yearning and anguished blues-rock belter with that stunning piano part.
Elsewhere there are some good songs: I Looked Away, Bell Bottom Blues, Keep on Growing, Why Does Love Got to Be So Sad, their version of Little Wing and Thorn Tree in the Garden and the Delaney & Bonnie (and of course Duane Allman) influence is clear in the shuffling, rootsy, country-blues feel of some of it.
However it also has many of the things that I sometimes struggle with with Clapton, a kind of extremely skilled sheen of dullness. The interplay with Duane Allman is lovely and fluid, and his slide playing is great, but even Clapton’s excellent playing in that context I don’t often find very appealing. I also find that, aside from Layla, his vocals are particularly inexpressive - obviously it’s not his fault he doesn’t have the strongest voice, but I’m just not that keen on his rather affected gruffness and bluesy mannerisms.
And it also sounds very samey for a 76 minute double album, and about halfway through Keys to the Highway you wonder if this is ever going to end, especially when it’s followed by Tell the Truth. Fortunately Why Does Love Got to Be So Bad gives a welcome shot of energy and tempo, and Little Wing’s superb intro/motif brings a welcome edge of drama and variation. And I wish there were more songs like Thorn Tree in the Garden, with its wistful, Traffic-esque folky blues standing out against the bluesy morass.
It’s between a 2 and a 3. As great as Layla and Bell Bottom Blues are, and as good as I Looked Away, Keep on Growing and Thorn Tree in the Garden are, I don’t know if they are enough to make me want to slog through the rest of it, as outside those songs it I do find it kind of boring. But then Layla really is one of rock's great songs. But ultimately I don’t think I want to listen to the whole thing again.
🎸🎸
Playlist submission: Layla