Like all the Madonna projects we’ve had on here so far, this one is very respectable and falls just short of something I’d call fantastic. Even if the production on this one is right in my wheelhouse.
“Swim” has one of many great vocal refrains, with the ‘we can’t carry the sins on our back’ line.
“Ray Of Light” has an even better hook thats made this song worth its popularity.
“Sky Fits Heaven”, more like This Song Fits Me with that late 90’s 4 on the floor kick turning this into a soft trance anthem.
“Shanti / Ashtangi” gave me some questions I need answered. Is this respectful and chill in eastern culture? So many artists use the Indian word for peace and do their ommmm Shantiiii’s. I really liked how Zedd did it in his most recent album. But is this all good? I genuinely don’t know.
This original version of “Frozen” is absolutely wonderful with its breakbeats and mellow yet dramatic atmosphere. It unfortunately escapes me, but somewhere there’s a really good remix or lift of this vocal thats more club-oriented.
Lastly, “Little Star” is a sweet song clearly meant for her child, and the album probably shoulda stopped here. I felt like “Mer Girl” was exactly when I started to tune out.
For my tastes personally this is a 4/5, William Orbit did a killer job on the production, Madonna’s voice is as good as ever. But maybe there’s a bit of meandering here and there. It’s a project that feels a bit stuck between needing to make sure it holds onto its pop essence while experimenting with these other sounds of trip-hop, trance, and eastern music. It isn’t a perfect marriage of the two in totality, but it’s solid over all. 3/5? 4/5? Tough call.