What other band had 10 such smart, strong, influential albums in a row like R.E.M. had from 1983-1996? The list begins with their debut LP Murmur and ends with New Adventures in Hi-Fi, their final album with all four founding members. Automatic for the People is the eighth, and considered by many their best. As for me: I subscribe to the view that there is no such thing as a greatest R.E.M. album, only personal favorites (often influenced by what year you came of age and/or first “met” the band).
One of the great things about THIS album is how it defied expectations, following their hugely successful Out of Time (think “Losing My Religion”). When this album was released, Mike Mills said that it probably would not sell like their previous album (it did) but they still thought it was a good album. Peter Buck said that in retrospect, no other album in 1993 sounded like theirs…“and that’s a good thing.”
The sound is spacious, reflective, somber, with edges of hope. So many songs address death and mortality that a rumor circulated that Michael Stipe was dying. As it turns out, he was grieving some big losses, but he is still with us to this day.
The genius here, and the beauty, is that the band followed their own musical direction, created something authentic, and found themselves once again on the leading edge for all the right reasons.
Not my favorite R.E.M. album, but in my Top 10 .... 5/5.