I have gone from hating Taylor to not really caring about her and to somewhat liking her. I watched her concert and I will be honest I didn’t know how poetic her songs were. So this was a nice experience to sit and listen to an entire album.
There is so much to dive into with Taylor. First her voice is beautiful, and it goes along with the subtle melodies and chords she has created. Song after song is calm, beautiful and subtle emotions of someone looking back. Criticism is that all of the songs are similar in terms of melody and tone, nothing makes me want to stand up and dance and nothing makes me want to cry. Its something I would have listened to in my late 20’s while cleaning the house.
The actual lyrics are poem after poem. Some have hooks and choruses, but most are just long poetic stories. She uses her words to craft depth, beauty and emotion into simple interactions. That might be part of the draw, all of these young middle/upper class individuals that feel their simple everyday lives are not noteworthy, connect with her because even in simple live there are deep noteworthy feelings we have.
In that she has the ability to pull out the simple toxicity in simple life (Tolerate It) and maybe that is why so many men hate her. She doesn’t allow light to everyday toxicity in relationships, she pulls at each moment shines a light on their behavior. In contrast, one thing she lacks is any accountability in her songs, mostly it is always about the others making her feel worthless, and they may have mostly sucked.
Happiness was one of the few where I really heard her reflect and discuss her side of things and that there was some accountability, and maybe that is because she took a lot of time to reflect. It was also really beautiful because so many of us have those feelings about some past relationships.
Its pretty, simple and complex. She has a talent for writing and connecting, and this album is a good example.