Reviews by melibretto

HorsesPatti Smith

Rated 6/10

Some good songs on here, but I kinda feel like a lot of them are ruined by trying to be a bit too arty…

I definitely enjoyed this more than when I listened to it for the AM top 100 albums

It takes a lot to deserve a 10 minute song and I don’t think this meets the criteria, let alone for 2 of them…

2.5

Feel like this is a bit all over the place, Maps is obviously a banger and one of the best songs ever, but everything else on here feels and sounds completely different

3

Not as good as pink moon but still pretty good, had a load of these songs stuck in my head for days after listening to this

3.5

3rdBig Star

Rated 6/10

Feel like this is trying a bit too hard to be both the velvet underground AND nico

For you was nice but I didn’t think much of the rest of this

2.5

MelodramaLorde

Rated 8/10

Personally for me not as good as her debut but still full of bangers I’d already heard and also some great songs that were new to me

4

Enjoyable at the time but I’ve forgotten pretty much everything about this already, probably means I need to give it another listen

3.5

Struggling to believe this isn’t just Jack Black under a different pseudonym

Really easy listening beautiful tracks, knew wild world and father and son already but this whole thing is really nice

4

LeftismLeftfield

Rated 6/10

Not really my thing but I didn’t exactly hate it either. Basically all blended into one

2.5

RevolverThe Beatles

Rated 10/10

Not their best imo but still a crazy good collection of songs let down by only a couple

Idk if it’s just my upbringing around a scouse parent and some scouse family but Yellow Submarine is scream along to worthy so I don’t understand the hate that gets

Here there and everywhere is in contention for best Beatles song for me, and got to get you into my life is also incredible

4.5

Pretty certain the title track is temu leper messiah

This was fine, nothing exciting that makes me want to listen to it again

3