While I do think 'It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back' is the better overall album, Public Enemy's 'Fear of a Black Planet' is ripe with experimentation, lyrical fury, and dizzying production that can easily overwhelm you upon first listen. I mean, I've listened to this album countless times, and I still think that it is a lot at times, but in a mostly good way.
The production here, and the album in general, feels like flicking through various news channels - songs like 'Contact On The World Love Jam' and 'Incident At 66.6 FM' especially play into this aesthetic. And if there's one thing that remains obvious about all these news samples we're flicking through, it's their disdain for Public Enemy, their music, and hip hop in general after their commercial break with 'It Takes A Nation...'. So, what this album ends up providing for the listener is Public Enemy's much-needed responses to the media's baseless, and mostly racist, claims.
But I'll jump to the lyrical side of things in a bit. First, I just want to stress how bat-shit insane the production on this thing is. It's untamed, and a sample warehouse - a Bomb Squad production that is the essence of "Throwing everything at the wall to see what sticks", and, miraculously enough, most of it sticks and leaves a permanent mark. The messy guitar sample and that funky bassline driving 'Brothers Gonna Work It Out' feel like a calm before the storm. The vocoded vocals of '911 is a Joke' are my favorite aspect of that particular song, though I also love the group ramblings that just hang in the background; they're absurd. 'Welcome To The Terradome' has too many incredible moments to list off - I mean, the core beat itself has this very industrial feel to it, and it's another example of the Bomb Squad just choosing an insanely bold, short sample loop to encompass their core beats. Some other small moments from this song that I love are the female vocals in the interlude, that one random electric guitar hit at the beginning of the second verse, and Flavor Flav's accent during the interlude. 'Anti Machine' has this insanely hypnotic groove driving a good chunk of the song, it lulls the listener into a false sense of security before hitting them across the head with D's verse in the final minute or so - I love the sound effects paired with his verse here. The whistle of 'Burn Hollywood Burn' alongside those horn hits makes for an explosive refrain, and the organ of the title track gives the entire song a very funky edge. 'War At 33 1/3' is the best beat here in my opinion, I love that wayward synth that drives the beat, it sounds like it's being perpetually tuned. And that screaming at the beginning of D's verse kills me every time. The other obvious highlight here is 'Fight The Power', just an incredible fucking beat - and not as chaotic as everything else here, sounding like something off their previous record. But even then, the sample list for this song tells another story; many smaller details in this beat can easily fly over your head on a first listen.
The lyrical intensity on this album is brought up a ton. These guys are fed up, and any sort of restraint that Chuck D had on their previous album is completely gone (not that there was much there to begin with). It works (mostly) well, with 'Meet The G That Killed Me' being a bit of a blemish on the rest of the album. '911 Is a Joke' actually has Flavor Flav rapping something meaningful, with some genuinely poignant commentary on first responders' apathy toward the black community, with Flav even saying he'd rather call a cab because it would come quicker. 'Burn Hollywood Burn' has PE welcoming some feature verses for once, from the best-of-the-best. Big Daddy Kane's verse here is incredible, just the way he comes in with his deeper caodence on this chunky beat is great. I love this posse cut because it remains focused on the core message of the song, which deals with the pigeonholing of black actors and roles in Hollywood. A few songs here, like 'Pollywanacraka' and the title track, deal with these ideas of race mixing, both providing very unique insights into the world's view on it. And 'Who Stole The Soul?' tackles the idea of persistent dehumanization of the black community at the hands of various government institutions throughout history. Finally, you have 'Fight The Power', one of the greatest musical anthems ever. That Elvis line is still one of my favorites to come out of the band, and I love the way the first part of that bar just repeats to hammer the idea home.
Going into the '90s, Public Enemy still sounded like they were operating on a completely different level than any other artist in hip-hop. Their group felt like an idea, a movement, and larger than music itself. They also just continued to sound really fucking good, everything fits so nicely in the mix despite the messy presentation.