Master of Puppets is the best metal album of all time. It's not my favorite Metallica album, but it's objectively a perfect album. For the time that this came out, nothing on the planet was anything like it. This album is one of if not the most important progressive metal precursors. Master of Puppets exemplified that metal could be more than just fast guitar solos and heavy riffs- that the songwriting could be brought up to a new level with complex structures and layers of orchestrations played through guitars. Not only is this album absolutely groundbreaking, but it fucking rips.
James Hetfield on Master of Puppets at the time was something the world had never seen. The anger that shrieks through these vocal performances should absolutely be more recognized. Every lyric you can feel and visualize so vividly- it's just awing. His rhythm playing is ruthless, with some of Metallica’s fastest and definitely heaviest riffs being composed on this project.
This is also Cliff Burton's last studio performance before his tragic death in a fatal bus accident. Master of Puppets is Cliff's magnum opus, with his passion for classical music shining through the song orchestrations and his Lovecraftian lyrics. What his contributions to bass playing did is immeasurable. The complexity this album has in terms of songwriting is pure fucking genius and it cannot be understated what he added to the band.
Kirk Hammett is definitely at his peak on this album in terms of soloing. Every song features some of the best metal leads of all time, with not a single miss. You can really hear every member shining on this record at their fullest, and it’s just so infectious.
Hell, even Lars was a demon on this thing. His thrash drumming was perfect, and his double kick on the faster tunes absolutely rip.
It starts small and sinister with Battery's acoustic chords and suspenseful stacking harmonies. Then it just explodes like a volcano, introducing us into the madness that this album is about to unveil. I could make an argument and say that Battery is the greatest metal opening track of all time, if not one of the greatest openers of all time in general. It perfectly encapsulates the sheer amount of rage, complexity, and heaviness that this album is going to offer. Kirk's solo absolutely rips too.
The title track is probably one of the most influential songs on the planet. The amount of people that started playing guitar because of this song (me included) is definitely not a small number. This exact song showed that thrash metal could be expanded into something much larger. The middle section is one of the greatest bridges in existence. Hetfield's solo under that hypnotizing progression makes you wish it was an eternity. The harmonies organized as well that sandwich the solo are, in my opinion, the best harmonies in their catalog, which is saying a lot. The sheer amount of ruthless technique in this song's main riffs are insane too. Living in the universe at the same time as this song is a privilege.
The Thing That Should Not Be is another credit to Master of Puppets immeasurable influence on the metal genre. This dark D standard tune is one of the nastiest sludge/doom metal precursors. Kirk's solo sounds like a demonic dolphin in the creepiest way possible. The main riff is also one of Metallica's most underrated parts. The lyrics however, are some of my favorites in Metallica's catalog. The ominous, terrifying, and unimaginable depiction of a Lovecraft inspired monster is just so fucking cool.
Sanitarium at most points was my favorite Metallica song, just absolutely perfect from start to finish. The best thing about this track by a mile are the 4 solos. These 2 melodic and 2 shredfest leads are some of the greatest recorded metal performances of all time. Welcome Home is a beast that gradually builds and builds from a haunting ballad to a thrash chainsaw as the intensity of the riffs and solos rise. The clean riff is also one of the most hauntingly beautiful things I've ever heard. The lyrics are also killer.
Disposable Heroes by Metallica has the greatest lyrics of all time. The vivid description of a soldier’s traumatizing role in society is shrieked perfectly by Hetfield. The motif ingeniously screams "BACK TO THE FRONT" by a sergeant to a soldier, playing on words and symbolizing the intensity of how all soldiers are crafted the same, led into battle to die. The riffs on this thing are incredibly intense too. Kirk’s choice of modes on his solo show that he’s getting very involved on this record. At this point in the band’s history, every member was at their peak, and this song exemplifies that for sure.
Leper Messiah is an underrated gem. This is one of the nastiest songs in Metallica’s catalog, sinisterly depicting the corruption of finance in religion. Throughout the whole album, each song reinforces the themes of evil corrupting the oblivious, which just makes the entire listen very cohesive. The progressive aspects of this song are super sick, specifically the bridge section where the track transforms into this thrashfest.
Orion. God this song is a progressive metal masterpiece. It begins with these bass drones along with crescendoing drums pulsing as the track begins to build to the break in the main theme. This song is Cliff’s masterpiece, as you can see 3 bass solos throughout it as well as the incredible orchestrated nature of the harmonies. The middle section transcends you, immersing the sound in the sonics of the galaxy. Every solo taken, every riff chug, and every bend strung in this song is just written for the gods.
Lastly, the album closes with Damage Inc. This is the last song that features Cliff Burton in the studio, and what he begins the track with could not be more perfectly fitting. The bass swells sound like a horn’s call, or like a full orchestra performing together, even though it’s just a bass. Because Cliff could do those things. Metallica were on a completely different level of songwriting while constructing this project, and the mixing, performances, lyrics, and riffs just prove this.
Master of Puppets start to finish is perfect. Not a single second is wasted, and the effort and genius in the songwriting blows my mind. Not another album in history is anything like this. I hope Cliff knows how much the world loves his masterpiece.