I’ll start this off by saying that I like the song “Cinnamon Girl.” I like the rhyme of “saxes” and “relaxes,” and the continuing almost-thrashy guitar. I also have to say that there’s a duck called a Cinnamon Teal, so whenever one comes to my attention I sing to myself “I wanna live with a Cinnamon Teal, I could be happy the rest of my life with a Cinnamon Teal.” So that’s a thing about that song.
“Down by the River” is a classic song - I love all the threatening guitar sounds that come in for that long break after the first set of vocals. Definitely merits its 9-minute length. I was thinking of a 3 for this album after "Round & Round," but then was reminded of what I like about Neil Young while listening to this song. I’ve just never been sure about this plot - what’s the timeline here, regarding the person sending him over the rainbow vs shooting his baby dead. But who cares, great guitar solo.
“Running Dry” sounds like “In the Pines,” doesn’t it. I like the strings that come in, and then go out at the end; it’s a poignant folk tune. I’d never heard this track before and I really like it.
Quibbles: I've never been a fan of the title track; I think it would be greatly improved if he got rid of all the la la la las. “Round & Round” is a little too smooth and goes on too long. He says it won’t be long, but it is long. And while “Cowgirl in the Sand” has some wonderful guitar solos, the lyrics have always gotten on my nerves.
So, tl:dr: there's some lovely guitar work on this album, which offsets a few annoying bits.