Rated 10/10
I find it intriguing to check out R.E.M.'s debut album after listening to their later records on my album journey. Because, from the sounds of Murmur, they started as more of a cross between garage rock and jangle pop. It's still apparent where the sonic direction will be going in the near future, but this early on, they nailed their distinct characteristics. Peter Buck's arpeggiated guitar playing, Mike Mills's countermelodic bass lines, Michael Stipe's abstract lyrics paired with the vocal harmonies, and Bill Berry's punchy percussion are all present here. Credit where it's due to producers Don Dixon and Mitch Easter, who employed a largely hands-off approach to capture the raw, live energy.
Speaking more about the lyrics, I was surprised by how many poignant messages could be extrapolated from this debut. From the perils of biased media on "Radio Free Europe", to finding safety in a difficult situation in "Laughing", to the starvation and hunger portrayed in "Talk About the Passion", to the loss of youth and innocence on "Catapult", there was a lot of resonance to be found in these songs. Even if a meaning couldn't be found for a particular track, there was enough intricate imagery and interconnected vowels to match the mood of the instrumental composition, such as in the ballad "Perfect Circle" and the bouncy folk-punk of "Sitting Still".
I couldn't find any issues with Murmur, as this ended up being a surprisingly vibrant debut record. It was nice checking out R.E.M. from their humble beginnings.