Reviews by mikltabey

It was OK and would’ve been a 3 if it were half as long. Got knocked down a star because I couldn’t not stop it early.

Not too bad.

Unsurprisingly, pretty great.

It was fine.

Eh. No, thanks.

A masterpiece. An easy 5 star, no skip album.

As a Paul Simon, I guess, super fan, I think this is his best album with or without Garfunkel.

Pretty decent

I really liked it!

I’ve really liked Love recently, It that last song drug this down.

It was fine.

I get why it’s on the list, but I’ve always thought it was a little bland. It never really did it for me.

I was between a 3 and a 4 on this. I think some of it is pretty good and some of it isn’t. I legit don’t think John was very good without Paul.

I did listen to album a LOT back when I was taking an Elvis Presley course in college. The professor had a whole thing about the “I don’t believe in Elvis” line and how he thought Elvis responded in his next album.

So, I bullshitted a 30 page paper about it and got an A.

I liked it. From what I’ve read, I’d be interested in listening to another album or two of his.

I reeeeeeaaaaaalllllllyyyy didn’t like it.

I know all the criticisms of this album. But I’ve loved this one since high school. I know it’s not a 5, but it’s a testament to how good Paul is that he can half-ass a 4 star album.

I thought I was giving CCRvanother 5, but this just didn’t do it for me as much.

I gotta say, I did not dig it at first, but was loving it by the end.

I like it a lot. It almost got a 5 from me, but ran a little long.

I kind of liked it, but only kind of

I wasn’t expecting to, but I really enjoyed it. It wasn’t a 5, or anything, but I sure did like it a 4 amount.