Rated 6/10
There are albums that, after listening to them, you simply don't know how to rate, because the only way to describe them is with the phrase "sometimes thick, sometimes thin."
For example, here's an album by Silver Jews, a band I'd never heard of before. Half the album is boring, semi-acoustic indie rock, like Wilco, the other half is pleasant, sensual music, like The National. The lyrics are sometimes good, Dylan-level, and sometimes, on the contrary, a bit hackneyed. The vocalist sometimes sings well, but sometimes it feels like he's incapable of it.
What's definitely undeniable about this album is its superb mixing. It's a unique case: sometimes the technical part is more enjoyable to listen to than the musical one.
At the same time, it's been on the list of "1001 Albums" since the very beginning, and it seems it's here to stay. Should I give it two stars? Well, it's not that bad. Three stars? That's a bit much... Maybe just a light one.