I find that popstars of the 2020s tend to be much better at ‘album craft’ than those from my childhood, but Christina Aguilera gives it a good go on Back to Basics. There are some era defining hits across the record but they are outnumbered on a double album which includes the occasional dud and plenty of tracks that fall somewhere in between. As with many double albums I am left feeling it would have been better lean and mean.
The quality difference between songs like Back in the Day and Ain’t No Other Man (which sit side by side on the first disc) is stark. Both tackle a clear lyrical concept head on but where the latter is a short shock of radio fuel, the former is an unwieldy, unconvincing mission statement.
I could have done with more chilled out ballads such as the excellent Thank You (Dedication to Fans…) and Hurt, or fabulous, dramatic songs such as Nasty Naughty Boy and Candy Man, all which display the “back to basics” songwriting which this album shouts about. I could have done with less vocal gymnastics throughout, but I understand that this is very much Aguilera’s brand and what was in vogue at the time.