It’s normally hard to defend a runtime of 80+ minutes. But this is essentially two albums in one.
And even if it wasn’t… It’s Nick Cave, he can do what he wants, shut up.
I first fell in love with the band around Dig, Lazarus, Dig!!! and the opening record of this double album, Abattoir Blues, hits that exact vibe with a howling and mad Nick Cave accompanied by the bluesy and frenzied Bad Seeds on a never ending stream of perfect songs where “Get Ready For Love”, “Hiding All Away” and “There She Goes, My Beautiful World” stand out in particular.
The second album, The Lyre of Orpheus, is a completely different record altogether. It’s more melodic and mellow with a Nick Cave in front that seems more aware of what The Bad Seeds would eventually become. In that regard, this double album seems to serve as a kind of portal leading from one era and into the next.
I personally prefer the first half, but both albums are undoubtedly 5 star records. So there’s no actual consideration going into the final score.