Not quite October yet, but this is a good spooky season album.
Prior to getting this, felt like I would have given it a 3 since I don't think it's as good as Marshall Mathers LP, but honestly this is hitting today for me. Could be the season, could just be it's better than I remember, either way, today's a good day.
I'm just going to ignore the skits. Most of them are pretty short anyways, and I typically don't count skits against an album.
It's interesting how out of place My Name Is on the album, given how upbeat it (And it's sample, Labi Siffre's I Got The) and weird it is when the rest of the tracklist is so dark with it's horrorcore styles.
Still fantastic and classic song, but yeah. Beyond that, this album is just filled with great flows and beats. Guilty Conscious is good, but the breaks to introduce the next character really slam the breaks on the momentum of the song. Brain Damage is fantastic with it's plinky guitars giving it that spooky vibe. If I Had is a more dark R&B style track that vibes, but I do think the lyrics/flow aren't as strong as some of his other stuff on the record.
Then you have '97 Bonnie & Clyde, the sequel to the absolutely harrowing Kim on the Marshall Mathers LP. Knowing Kim, this song kinda loses some of it's horror when you know that it gets so much worse. This song is kinda quaint in comparison, although still solid.
Role Model brings back some plinky guitars that gives that Halloween in Detroit vibe that I love. Couple that with an insane flow from Eminem, just a fantastic song. Classic Slim Shady song.
After that, the album does start to drag a tad with My Fault and Cum on Everybody, two songs that I would honestly drop from the album. Side note: If you dropped the skits (I'd leave Public Service Announcement) and those two songs, this could honestly be a really tight 50 minute album that might be a 5/5.
But Em brings it back with Rock Bottom, probably on of the best tracks on the entire record. Guitars on this album are just bringing the horror vibes and I love it.
Just Don't Give A Fuck is a solid track. The the screaming bell sound does get old by the end of the song, but a great flow from Eminem keeps it interesting. As the World Turns, I'm Shady, Bad Meets Evil, and Still Don't Give A Fuck just keeps things moving though and finish off the album nicely. Feel like I could appreciate those songs more if My Fault and Cum On Everybody were dropped, just because the runtime does exhaust a little by the end.
But yeah. Classic record from Em, better than I remembered. I'm sure some of my praise of this and MMLP are due to me being from Detroit and kinda feeling like I need to hype up artists from my area (Especially as Eminem's reputation has kinda took a hit with his later albums not being that great), but SSLP and MMLP are legitimately great albums.
I'lll have to relisten to MMLP again. I do remember it having similar issues with it kinda having a few songs that aren't up to snuff, but the highs are definitely higher than on SSLP.