I know that I enjoyed the hell out of Stankonia as album #64 on my journey, and I wasn't alone in my sentiment. The album received critical acclaim and racked up multiple awards. So much was the success of Stankonia and Outkast in general that when André 3000 wanted to pursue a solo career and create an album more focused on jazz and pop, the group's label, Arista Records, wanted to pull the plug on it because they felt it would be a bad career move for him. But André still wanted to make his own record, thus, the next best thing was to package it with Big Boi's finished solo record and sell them together under the Outkast moniker. That's how we ended up with Speakerboxxx/The Love Below.
This double album is simply two solo albums placed side-by-side; there's no beating around the bush about it. Sure, Big Boi and André 3000 contributed additional vocals and co-production credits for each other's records, and both records have multiple interlude tracks that are pointless and, at worst, come off as self-indulgent. Other than that, these are two separate albums from two gentlemen who may belong to the same group but are experiencing creative differences. As such, I can't discuss Speakerboxxx/The Love Below without discussing each disc separately.
Let's start with Speakerboxxx, Big Boi's solo record. This one is a Southern progressive hip-hop record with Parliament-Funkadelic vibes, and it very much reflects how consistent Big Boi had been in his songwriting. There are bangers upon bangers throughout this side - "GhettoMusick", "Bowtie", "The Way You Move", "The Rooster", "War", "Church", "Knowing", and the list goes on. We also get some incredible guest features, including the team-up of Konkrete, Big Gipp and Ludacris on "Tomb of the Boom", Lil Jon & the East Side Boyz on "Last Call", and not one but TWO Killer Mike features on "Bust" and "Flip Flop Rock" with Jay-Z. Honestly, I would have been content with Speakerboxxx on its own as it built upon Big Boi's previous successes to have a great, if not perfect, solo album.
But then we have The Love Below, André 3000's record. In embracing jazz and experimental music with a more sensual side, André just comes off like Prince. After opening up the record with a Frank Sinatra style intro into the noise-rock meets lounge swing of "Love Hater", André proceeds to run through multiple sex jams in the pursuit of love after his fallout with Erykah Badu, a point which he makes on closing track "A Life in the Day of Benjamin André (Incomplete)". For sure, there are bangers to be found here, including "Happy Valentine's Day", "Roses", "Dracula's Wedding" with Kelis, and especially "Hey Ya!" as the group's biggest single. Not to mention, two of André's greatest soul tracks are placed back-to-back in "Prototype" and "She Lives in My Lap" with Rosario Dawson, and I also dug the laid-back dub-jazz trip of "Vibrate". But not every experiment on The Love Below is a success, even if they came from interesting ideas. The horniness goes awry in the back-to-back "Spread" and "Where Are My Panties", and I did not care much for the falsetto-sung "She's Alive" about single motherhood. I didn't feel Norah Jones was much of a presence on the short acoustic tune "Take Off Your Cool". Finally, while it was neat hearing a drum-and-bass rendition of "My Favorite Things" from The Sound of Music, it didn't need to go on for five minutes.
At the end of the day, both Speakerboxxx and The Love Below are solid albums that would have done fine on their own, though I'll admit I preferred the consistent quality of the former. The problem is that their label forced the two to come together as a double album, and the experience as a whole ends up bloated. Go through each record separately and make what you will, but the industry machinations behind the scenes cannot be ignored here.