With The Beatles
I’m going to give this a 5 - it’s the Beatles, I’m emotionally dependent on them and there’s not enough Beatles in the World - but it’s probably my least listened album of theirs, or the one I have tended to find least interesting, sandwiched between two albums that I frequently return to. Please Please Me I love, as even 60 years later it's still imbued with the novelty and excitable charm of the group and you can feel the early 60s-ness of it all, and A Hard Day’s Night, which is a superb showcase of their quickly developing sophistication and cultural impact. And in my mind it even lacks some of the slightly frazzled oddness and hidden gems of Beatles for Sale.
But having said that, this is an excellent listen, with a marked depth of sound compared to PPM. It might be a consequence of the more recent CD remastering but there is a noticeable growl to the bass on It Won’t Be Long as well as more depth to it on All I’ve Got to Do, with those two songs and the sweet pop perfection of All My Loving making an excellent opening 3 tracks. It Won’t Be Long is one of my favourite early songs of theirs and the highlight of the album, a superb distillation of their early style and a hint at their ability to seemingly casually toss off moments of melodic and harmonic brilliance - a lovely descending guitar hook, a typically great off beat Lennon rhythm guitar part, a memorable tune and a winning energy and charm.
Don’t Bother Me has really grown on me over the years, George’s sullen delivery is fantastic, and I very much enjoy the sentiment of the lyrics (and the odd, thumping percussion sound at the coda). Aside from the twin classical guitars I’ve never really been that enamoured by Till There Was You, although I do like how it sits between the catchily throwaway Little Child and Please Mr Postman, with its superb lead and backing vocals. Hold Me Tight I think is a bit of a hidden gem - it seems to be very lowly regarded, and although Macca goes a bit out of tune it’s got an almost punkish energy, a great, grating guitar sound and propulsive rhythm. Not a Second Time is a bit of the inverse of Hold Me Tight for me. With William Mann’s analysis it seems to be held in high critical esteem, and while I think I can appreciate the moment of Aeolian Cadence on ‘You Hurt Me Then’, I’ve never really been struck by it.
Of the covers, Money is superb, alongside Twist and Shout their best cover, sharing a similarly raucous and committed Lennon vocal, and I always enjoy the slightly sloppy version of Roll Over Beethoven and the fun of Please Mr Postman. And You Really Got a Hold On is another of their best covers.
If this was an exercise of ranking only Beatles albums out of 5 it's probably a 4, it is certainly uneven, but if you compare it to any of their contemporaries 2nd or 3rd albums or many other rock/pop albums from 1963 it's on a completely different level. Thanks of course to George Martin and Norman Smith it sounds excellent, and they were already streets ahead in songwriting terms, even if they hadn’t reached the zenith of their pre Rubber Soul period.
🪲🪲🪲🪲🪲
Playlist submission: It Won’t Be Long
Ps - one slight non musical thing, even though the cover is still fantastically striking, I wish Ringo wasn’t just stuck in the bottom corner like an afterthought.