I think the more I think about the story, the less I care for it. I gave this two attentive listens to really make my mind up on it, the first of which was on a walk, generally unfocused on the lyrics. As a result, that time around I completely missed a lot of the suffercore aspects on the first half which, on re-listen with the lyrics up, really became my main gripe with the album. I just feel like it spends a disproportionate amount of runtime on the childhood traumas compared to the comparatively short and abrupt cult arc. The execution feels overall clunky, especially having experienced The Wall in the past.
Story aside though, these guys really came through with the arrangements. This isn't The Who I had come to know! The bar was low with My Generation and The Who Sell Out, but this sounds like an outright different band. I respect the ambition!
Standouts: Christmas • Underture • We're Not Gonna Take It