I think I understand the problem artists faced in the vinyl era: you either released a single LP of about 40–45 minutes, or you went for a double album. And if you had more material than would fit on one record, you suddenly had a lot more space to fill.
I had a similar issue with Pink Floyd’s The Wall. One LP wouldn’t have been enough to tell the whole story, but two felt excessive, as though some material was there just to fill the sides.
And now George Harrison takes it even further!
I understand that he’d accumulated years of unreleased songs during his time with The Beatles. And there’s some truly excellent music here. Harrison is a fantastic guitarist, songwriter, and singer. I genuinely think a carefully selected single LP could have been a 5/5 album.
But somewhere during the second LP, I started losing interest. Not because the songs were bad, but because there was simply too much of the same good thing. And then there’s an entire third LP of instrumental jams!
Yesterday I listened to Miles Davis’s Bitches Brew. It’s over an hour and a half long, but somehow every minute felt justified. So it’s not the length itself that bothers me.
It’s the OVERSHARING!
George, I admire your talent, but come on! Nearly two hours? You made this for yourself, not for the audience!